Tau Boötis b: A ’3-D’ Look at Star and Planet

by Paul Gilster on February 25, 2014

Strong evidence for water in the atmosphere of the hot Jupiter Tau Boötis b has turned up, thanks to work by Geoffrey Blake (Caltech) and graduate student Alexandra Lockwood. But what’s intriguing about the find isn’t the water — we’ve found water vapor on other planets — but the method of detection. Lockwood and Blake used a modified radial velocity technique that has previously been deployed to detect low mass ratio binary stars. A top-flight instrument like the Near Infrared Echelle Spectrograph (NIRSPEC) at the W. M. Keck Observatory in Hawaii can separate the planetary and stellar components spectroscopically to produce this result.

bootis

Image: Simulated data showing the method used for detecting water vapor features around the hot Jupiter tau Boötis b. In this example, the planetary signal has been increased in strength by several orders of magnitude relative to the actual signal. The dotted lines show the blue- and red-shifts of the planetary and stellar lines in the data, respectively. Credit: Alexandra Lockwood/Caltech.

Thus the toolkit of exoplanet science continues to grow. We already know how to study planetary atmospheres when a planet transits its primary as seen from Earth, allowing us to separate direct light from the star from light that has passed through the atmosphere. Another way of studying an atmosphere is through direct imaging, but here we rely on planets far enough from their host star that we can separate them from the star’s glare, the classic problem of planet hunters. But a non-transiting world like Tau Boötis b demands a different approach, and the spectroscopic separation of radial velocity signals appears to be one solution.

Lockwood is lead author of the paper on this work, which appears in The Astrophysical Journal Letters:

“The information we get from the spectrograph is like listening to an orchestra performance; you hear all of the music together, but if you listen carefully, you can pick out a trumpet or a violin or a cello, and you know that those instruments are present. With the telescope, you see all of the light together, but the spectrograph allows you to pick out different pieces; like this wavelength of light means that there is sodium, or this one means that there’s water.”

It was back in 2012 that two independent teams studying Tau Boötis b were able to separate the radial velocity of the planet from that of the star by studying shifts in the spectral lines of carbon dioxide. The technique as expanded into the infrared now gives us the molecular signature of water. I should mention here that a team in 2010 detected carbon monoxide in the atmosphere of another hot Jupiter, the much studied HD 209458 b, a detection that provided what researchers call the ‘spectroscopic orbit’ of the system and thus revealed the true mass of the planet.

So more is at play here than the detection of yet another component of a hot Jupiter’s atmosphere. Separating the two radial velocity components helps to determine a planet’s mass, which in earlier radial velocity studies could only be an estimate of the planet’s minimum mass. The actual mass could be much higher than what astronomers could measure, given their lack of knowledge about the inclination of the planet to the star. By detecting a signature from both planet and star, this method allows us to explore the system in greater detail. From the paper (with reference to the 2012 work on carbon dioxide mentioned above):

…this technique can be applied to non-transiting, RV-detected exoplanets to extract the unknown inclination and true mass. CRIRES [the High-Resolution IR Echelle Spectrometer installed at ESO’s Very Large Telescope] was also used to detect CO on τ Boötis b (Brogi et al. 2012), the first ground-based detection of a short-period non-transiting exoplanet atmosphere, a result confirmed shortly thereafter by Rodler et al. (2012). These studies provide the true mass of the planet and probe the chemical composition of its atmosphere. A combination of high signal-to-noise, high spectral resolution, and coverage of multiple CO overtone lines was required to achieve the sensitivity required for these detections.

So by finding the signature of water in the atmosphere of Tau Boötis b, the Caltech team is also extending work that creates what Lockwood calls the ‘3-D motion of the star and the planet in the system.’ It’s a method that deepens our understanding of the planetary system by giving us a true mass reading, and although at present its applications are limited to close-in gas giants like Tau Boötis b around nearby bright stars, the hope is that improvements in telescopes and infrared spectroscopy will extend the method to smaller planets around dimmer stars.

“While the current state of the technique cannot detect earthlike planets around stars like the Sun, with Keck it should soon be possible to study the atmospheres of the so-called ‘super-Earth’ planets being discovered around nearby low-mass stars, many of which do not transit,” adds Blake. “Future telescopes such as the James Webb Space Telescope and the Thirty Meter Telescope (TMT) will enable us to examine much cooler planets that are more distant from their host stars and where liquid water is more likely to exist.”

The paper is Lockwood et al. “”Near-IR Direct Detection of Water Vapor in tau Boötis b,” The Astrophysical Journal Letters, published online 24 February 2014 (preprint).

tzf_img_post

{ 4 comments… read them below or add one }

Ronald February 26, 2014 at 13:18

This just in:
‘Super-Earths’ may be dead worlds: Being in habitable zone is not enough:
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/02/140226074925.htm
http://www.ras.org.uk/news-and-press/news-archive/254-news-2014/2408-super-earths-may-be-dead-worlds
http://mnras.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2014/02/17/mnras.stu085

Well, we knew that, but the really interesting question is: at which mass is the boundary between truly earthlike and mini-Neptune?
The articles are not entirely clear about this, but my impression is that the upper limit for earthlike is somewhere around 2 – 3 Me.

andy February 26, 2014 at 18:36

@Ronald: Aha nice to see this one get a press release, I’d mentioned it in a previous comment thread when it appeared on the arXiv. Interesting symbol they use in the press release to represent deuterium…

Ronald February 27, 2014 at 7:15

And just in, a bunch of new Kepler planets:

Mega Discovery! 715 Alien Planets Confirmed Using A New Trick On Old Kepler Data
http://www.universetoday.com/109764/mega-discovery-715-alien-planets-confirmed-using-a-new-trick-on-old-kepler-data/#more-109764
http://www.nasa.gov/ames/kepler/digital-press-kit-kepler-planet-bonanza/

Also with regard to my previous comment, the earthsized category (< 1.25 Re) is growing rapidly.

Ronald February 27, 2014 at 7:55

@andy: yes, there are a lot of interesting things to notice about both the super-earth/mini-Neptune issue and the new Kepler discoveries, but I will leave that for the articles concerned, which Paul is undoubtedly going to post soonest :-)

Leave a Comment