≡ Menu

Keeping an Eye on Psyche

What makes the asteroid 16 Psyche interesting is that it may well be the exposed core of a planet from the early days of Solar System formation, a nickel-iron conglomeration that normally would lie well below a surface mantle and crust. It’s also an M-class asteroid, a category of which it is the largest known sample. These are mostly made of nickel-iron and thought to be fragmented cores, though many have a composition that has not yet been determined.

Image: Deep within the terrestrial planets, including Earth, scientists infer the presence of metallic cores, but these lie unreachably far below the planets’ rocky mantles and crusts. Because we cannot see or measure Earth’s core directly, asteroid Psyche offers a unique window into the violent history of collisions and accretion that created the terrestrial planets. Credit: University of Arizona.

M-class asteroids have been imaged before — the Rosetta spacecraft imaged the non-metallic 21 Lutetia in 2010, and 216 Kleopatra has been imaged by ES0’s 3.6 meter telescope at La Silla as well as Arecibo — but now we’ll see one from close orbit.

For Psyche will be visited by a spacecraft of the same name, slated for launch in 2022 via Falcon Heavy, with arrival in 2026 after a 3.5-year cruise under solar electric propulsion. A single Mars flyby will occur along the way. The plan is to spend 21 months in orbit around the asteroid. You’ll recall that this mission will be testing NASA’s DSOC package (Deep Space Optical Communication), using laser techniques to communicate with Earth, See Deep Space Network: A Laser Communications Future for more on the DSOC and its capabilities.

The Psyche spacecraft’s Hall thrusters, using solar arrays as the power source, will be used beyond lunar orbit for the first time in this mission. The propellant is xenon, a neutral gas that will be accelerated and expelled from the spacecraft by electromagnetic fields after being ionized, producing a now familiar blue beam. The spacecraft will carry 922 kilograms of xenon, enough to run the Hall thrusters for years without exhausting available fuel supplies. NASA engineers estimate that chemical methods would require about five times that amount of propellant to achieve the same mission.

Image: The photo on the left captures an operating electric Hall thruster identical to those that will propel NASA’s Psyche spacecraft, which is set to launch in August 2022 and travel to the main asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter. The xenon plasma emits a blue glow as the thruster operates. The photo on the right shows a similar non-operating Hall thruster. The photo on the left was taken at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Southern California; the photo on the right was taken at NASA’s Glenn Research Center.

We have fairly scant information about Psyche, as witnessed by the image below, which comes out of an asteroid-imaging project nicknamed HARISSA that is being run by the European Southern Observatory, using adaptive optics on the Very Large Telescope. The survey data along with ground-based radar imaging has determined that Pyche is roughly 226 kilometers wide and contains two interesting surface features, the first of which is a bright area christened Panthia. The second is a huge crater about half the size of the asteroid itself, which the ESO team calls Meroe. No moons have turned up in this work, at least none larger than one kilometer, eliminating one marker for determining the asteroid’s mass.

Image: Views of Psyche from the HARISSA survey, with Meroe and Panthia highlighted. Credit: ESO/LAM.

Orbiting between 378 and 497 million kilometers from the Sun, between the orbits of Mars and Jupiter, Psyche takes five years to complete an orbit, with a rotation period of a little over four hours. If the asteroid is the core of what would have been a planet-sized object, the mission’s science instruments should be able to make the call. They include a multi-spectral imager, a magnetometer, a radio instrument for gravity measurement (tricky at this potato-shaped object) and a gamma-ray and neutron spectrometer. We can hope this will be sufficient to untangle a past likely marked by violent collisions in the era in which the planets were forming.

To keep up with Psyche mission developments from the inside, check the Psyche blog at Arizona State. Here’s a snip from the most recent entry (June 14), from Paige Arthur, who captures some of the excitement of being involved in a deep space mission at building 179, the famed home of JPL’s Spacecraft Assembly Facility:

Engineers and technicians adorned in lab coats, gloves, masks, and hair nets meander around on the floor below, taking measurements with multimeters and mating connectors not too different from the ones Will and I had been handling in the testbed moments before. Along the opposite wall are plaques commemorating all of the spacecraft that have been assembled there — Mariner, Ranger, Voyager, Galileo, Cassini, Curiosity, Opportunity, and, most recently, Perseverance. But in this moment I don’t notice any of it, because my attention is totally captured by the massive spacecraft suspended in the middle.

The Psyche Chassis is a huge black, silver, and gold box the size of a car with an antenna dish fixed to one end. Long struts surround the dish like the spindly legs of a massive aluminum spider, and red electronic boards connected by thick, snaking cords populate the sides. I’ve spent the last two and a half years at JPL working with software simulations and engineering models, with bits of pieces of Psyche’s brain, eyes, and heart, but seeing the physical manifestation of all that work suspended before me in the form of such a tremendous machine still brings me chills.

I’ve never worked on a spacecraft, but I’ve felt the chills, particularly at JPL one day many years ago when I watched Spirit and Opportunity being readied for shipment to Florida. Go Psyche.

{ 8 comments… add one }
  • Mike September 23, 2021, 12:55

    Prospecting is always the first step before mining. Go Psyche, indeed.

  • whomever1 September 23, 2021, 13:15

    My mind is somewhat boggling over the thought of getting into an orbit around an asteroid with an unknown mass. How much of the orbital mechanics will be handled by the craft itself, vs. folks at home?

  • Alex Tolley September 23, 2021, 15:21

    Reducing the areal density of current solar sails to 1/10 of their current values would allow the Psyche probe to deliver its payload with a sail just 42m x 42 m in area. This seems well within the roadmap for solar sail development. Or we can accept slower transit times to reach the asteroid.

    If so, a future asteroid mission using sails could not only be far less massive (~ 60 kg payload + sail vs 1600 kg) allowing more probes per launch, but when teh first rendezvous is complete, further rendezvous can be done as there is no propellant constraint.

    25 sail probes could be launched for the same mass as one Xe propellant electric engine Psyche mass probe. This is the sort of possibility as discussed in the previous post about looking for artifacts in our solar system. 25x the possible targets within teh same time frame, and an additional 25 for every subsequent period. The science is achieved by cataloging asteroid composition and features, as well as improving the technology of sails – material and design as well as navigation techniques.

    With regards to Psyche, while we have examples of NiFe asteroid material from meteorites on Earth, we could compare Psyche to other NiFe asteroids if that has value, as well as other asteroid types including dead comets. All the while piggy-backing a BOLO for anomalous objects in free space or on asteroids.

    • Robert September 24, 2021, 13:07

      You are saying if solar sails were 10x less massive for the same area, they could replace the solar electric engine on Psyche. Are there current prospects for such improvement? Solar electric engines might get a lot better also. Both would be nice. It’s good to have options.

      • Alex Tolley September 24, 2021, 14:56

        if solar sails were 10x less massive for the same area, they could replace the solar electric engine on Psyche.

        Yes. Bear in mind that the mass of the solar sail would be about the same as the electric engine and that there would be no propellant mass. I assumed the same acceleration as the electric engines. A caveat is that I was making rough calculations and could have made an error.

        If one can accept a slower time for the mission, then the current sail technology would be adequate.

        As for sail development, NASA has a roadmap for sails 1/100 the areal density of NEA Scout. Therefore I don’t think asking for about 16g/m^2 is asking too much in terms of technology development.

        Les Johnson would be the expert on this.

        I am a fan of electric engines, whether using solar PV, beamed power, or nuclear for power. What I want is very high Isp engines. The Psyche Hall Effect engine only has an Isp of 1800 seconds, 4-5x than of chemical, and 2x NTR. Not particularly impressive compared to existing Xe propellant ion engines which have much higher Isp.

        But the main attraction of solar sailing is that it is propellantless. There is no restriction on mission targets, so the craft can operate until it or the instruments fail. Either onboard navigation or automated ground control could steer the craft with little human input until the target was reached. 10-20 years of operation per sailcraft might be quite a low cost and deliver a lot of data on different asteroids, or even other bodies like moons.

        Despite their long history, it has taken a long time for solar sail technology to be developed. Recall that the World Space Foundation was trying to kick start solar sailing by 1990 (c.f. Project Solar Sail, which was furthered by the Planetary Society while there were no solar sail missions by any agency being developed after NASA abandoned the 1986 Halley mission using an advanced heliogyro sail design. This seems to have changed, especially as it appears that beamed sails might be the easiest way to reach the high velocities needed to reach the nearest stars in a reasonable time.

        And naturally, like some technologies, there is just the romance of using natural forces for propulsion. Despite the ending of the age of sail for oceanic travel, sailing remains a very popular activity, and there is something about traveling on a sailing ship knowing that you can travel as long as you like without needing to refuel. Solar sailing is rather similar, and even more practical in deep space where there are no places to refuel rocket engines.

    • Jeff Wright September 25, 2021, 23:43

      How close do other bodies in the region get to Psyche?

      Could it’s orbit be changed?

      You were talking about sails.

      Suppose I were to start extruding metal out of psyche as a wire….I have been able to drag cables too heavy to lift. These could perhaps be charged…

  • Supernaut September 24, 2021, 18:21

    Very interesting, thanks; 922 kg of Xe! Did Psyche’s Hall thrusters come from the bus vendor? That is, when the bus arrived, did it have the thrusters already mounted?

  • Mike Serfas September 28, 2021, 19:53

    To echo Mike above (no relation) … are there any “interesting” models of a planetary core, that turn out not just to be a big mass of iron, but would have narrow shell(s) (less than a kilometer) of some more exotic bullion arranged near the interface with the mantle, or at the deepest center of the core?

Leave a Comment