Edwin Salpeter and the Gasbags of Jupiter

by Paul Gilster on February 25, 2009

By Larry Klaes

‘The Gasbags of Jupiter’ sounds for all the world like the title of an early 1930s novel that would have run in a venue like Science Wonder Stories. In fact, as Larry Klaes tells us below, the idea grew out of Carl Sagan’s speculations about free-floating life-forms that might populate the atmospheres of gas giant planets like Jupiter. Cornell physicist Edwin Salpeter had much to do with the evolution of that concept, helping Sagan produce a paper that was a classic of informed imagination (and one that led to numerous science fiction treatments as the idea gained currency). Larry’s celebration of Salpeter’s life gives a nod to that paper but also notes his deep involvement in the study of the most distant celestial objects.

On March 14, the Department of Astronomy at Cornell University will commemorate the life of one of their most prestigious faculty members: Edwin E. Salpeter, the James Gilbert White Distinguished Professor of Physical Sciences Emeritus. Salpeter died of leukemia last November 26 at his home in Ithaca, just before his 84th birthday.

At the Heart of the Quasar

The biographies on Salpeter, who came to Cornell in 1948, primarily mention his work in the astrophysics of distant cosmic objects. As just one example, Salpeter was among the first scientists to come up with the current explanation for the enormous energies from quasars, which is short for QUAsi-StellAr Radio sources. The cores of these very distant galaxies contain supermassive black holes which collect vast amounts of debris that are pulled into fast-spinning accretion disks around these gravitational wells.

salpeter_pic_2

So much debris falls onto these black holes that it is often ejected back into deep space in relatively tight beams known as relativistic jets, which shoot out across intergalactic space for many thousands of light years. Quasars are some of the most luminous objects in the Universe and thanks to Salpeter’s work on understanding their nature, astronomers have a much better idea how these distant bodies are such powerhouses.

Image: The physicist Edwin Salpeter, photographed in 1978. Credit: Cornell University.

But perhaps the most recognized work of Salpeter is, ironically, one that many probably do not know he was involved with, or that his collaborator was one of the most recognized names and faces in science: The late Cornell astronomer Carl Sagan, who died in December of 1996 from myelodysplasia, a rare form of leukemia.

Pushing Habitability to New Extremes

Among Sagan’s many and varied interests, perhaps his favorite was extraterrestrial life. Sagan was one of the pioneers who brought about the acceptance by the mainstream science community of the possibility that beings of all kinds existed beyond our planet Earth. He would often speculate on alien life on worlds and in realms few had considered at the time.

One of Sagan’s truly revolutionary ideas about aliens was the concept of creatures that dwelled not on or in the surface of some Earthlike planet but spent their entire lives floating in the atmosphere of giant gaseous worlds such as Jupiter, which could hold over one thousand Earths. Unlike the inner terrestrial worlds such as Venus and Mars, Jupiter and its fellow giants are made up primarily of atmospheric gases, though the incredible pressures in these worlds’ lower layers of air turns the hydrogen in them into a metal.

Sagan thought that since the upper atmosphere of Jupiter was relatively friendlier by comparison and contained many complex organic molecules, they may have had time in the five billion years since the formation of the Solar System to turn out some type of life, an aerial form of creature that never touched or knew a planetary surface.

To determine just how scientifically plausible such aliens might be, Sagan asked his colleague Salpeter to help him produce a paper on the subject which was titled “Particles, Environments, and Possible Ecologies in the Jovian Atmosphere.” The paper first appeared in the prestigious The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series in late 1975.

A Jovian Taxonomy

Sagan and Salpeter envisioned three main types of Jovian creatures. There were sinkers, small organisms which were constantly falling towards the deadly deep, dense, and hot layers of the planet but always managed to survive long enough to produce offspring that would stay up in the more habitable air layers to repeat their cycle of life. The other aerial residents of Jupiter were known as floaters, which Sagan would later describe as being “kilometers across, enormously larger than the greatest whale that ever was, beings the size of cities.” Floaters were seen as drifting across the vast alien sky in great herds, looking like a collection of immense balloons, which in essence there were, using the lighter elements of Jupiter’s atmosphere to stay aloft.

cosmos_jovian

Image: Salpeter and Sagan’s Jovian aerialists, as imagined by the artist Adolf Schaller.

As with life on Earth, the Jovian ecosystem would also have its share of predators which Sagan and Salpeter named, appropriately, hunters. The hunters were envisioned as being fast and able to maneuver, preying on the floaters “for their organic molecules and for their stores of pure hydrogen.”

Love and Death Among the Gasbags

As author William Poundstone stated in his 1999 biography Carl Sagan: A Life in the Cosmos about this paper and its authors, “they produced one of the more singular scientific articles of the time, a quantitative analysis (with sixty equations) of life, love, and death in the air of Jupiter.” Poundstone was especially amused about Sagan and Salpeter’s speculations on how such Jovian natives might reproduce, highlighting the paper’s statement that “the distinction between hunting and mating under these conditions is not sharp.”

The paper also noted that the two Voyager space probes scheduled to make flybys of Jupiter in 1979 had cameras powerful enough to just resolve the floaters if such beings existed at that world and were high up enough to be spotted. Whether the images of Jupiter’s swirling, colorful face that were later returned by the twin robot explorers were ever scrutinized for any floaters remains unknown.

Landmark as this paper was, it was the appearance by the Jovian aerial beings in Sagan’s equally landmark television series Cosmos that brought this concept to the general public. In the second episode of the thirteen-part PBS series first shown in 1980, the Jovians were briefly introduced in a magnificent painting made by artist Adolf Schaller. Sagan also mentioned his colleague by name as the person who helped to bring these strange beings to life in both the episode and in the companion book to the series. The Cornell scientist noted that even if sinkers, floaters, and hunters did not actually live on Jupiter, they might still dwell on some other worlds in the Milky Way galaxy.

More information on the Cornell commemoration of Edwin E. Salpeter, which takes place on March 14 at Barnes Hall, can be found here. The classic Salpeter and Sagan paper is “Particles, Environments and Possible Ecologies in the Jovian Atmosphere,” Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series, vol. 32, Dec. 1976, pp. 737-755 (available online).

{ 23 comments }

James M. Essig February 25, 2009 at 11:48

Hi Paul;

The possibility of floaters and hunters as envisioned in the above artist rendering is so cool it is just plain freaky. Yet, such life forms may be a possibility within the Jovian atmosphere. If such life forms can arise in Jupiter with a finite probability, then in an infinite universe, with an infinite number of Gas Giant Planets in orbit about 5 AU to 15 AU from a parent star wherein the star is a G-2 or sun class star, such floaters and hunters should have evolved on an infinite number of planets.

By the way, the depictions are beautiful and show how pure art work can augment and popularize astronomy.

Thanks;

Jim

Goldstein Hovercraft February 25, 2009 at 12:51

What a fun post! Thanks!

“Particles, Environments, and Possible Ecologies in the Jovian Atmosphere.” by Sagan and Salpeter can be found in full, for free, here: http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/1976ApJS…32..737S/0000737.000.html
(via http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1976ApJS…32..737S)

— Eric

kurt9 February 25, 2009 at 15:15

I would be good to find intelligent life of this kind. They could sell us all of the Earth-like worlds that they have found and we can sell them all of the gas-giants that we find. Someone negotiates the sale of Jupiter to some gas bags in return for an asteroid belt in another system near the end of “Schismatrix”.

andy February 25, 2009 at 15:30

Maybe some of the gas giants found in the water zones of their stars might be better bets than Jupiter itself. A Neptune-type planet (which would be more enriched in metals than a Jupiter-type one) located in the habitable zone could offer interesting possibilities, and the gravity on such a planet would be relatively Earthlike. The outer planet of the HD 69830 system might fit the bill.

Adam February 25, 2009 at 22:20

Even our own Neptune gets pretty warm as you travel downwards – perhaps it’s wet enough for something to evolve? Energy sources would be a major issue so a planet closer to the Sun may be a better locale for an aerial biosphere.

Mattt February 26, 2009 at 10:51

Iain Banks paints a fantastic picture of gas giant lifeforms in “the algebraist” suggesting that those life forms are actually the most common in the universe but that they never took hold in our system because the gas giants here are “deserts”.

Administrator February 26, 2009 at 11:35

I’ve also enjoyed reading about Banks’ ‘dirigible behemothaurs’ in Look to Windward. Fascinating writer.

Adam February 26, 2009 at 16:17

Banks’ is also fond of the comical depiction of ETIs. His description of “The Affront” – from a Neptune type planet – is quite reminiscent of old “Benny Hill” sketches, which is a bit odd for a bunch of floating jelly-fish like aliens. David Brin also has gas giant aliens, called Zhang as a generic term, in his “Uplift War” continuation novels. They live in an uneasy relationship with oxygen breathers due to their mutual incomprehension, though they can co-operate.

It would certainly help explain the Fermi Paradox if most ETIs lived on gas giants.

Invader Xan February 27, 2009 at 6:20

Perhaps great minds really do think alike. It just so happens, I was writing about Sagan and Salpeter’s jovian ecologies a couple of evenings ago! :)

http://invaderxan.livejournal.com/74825.html

Interestingly, while as far as I know no evidence for life has been found on Jupiter, I don’t think anyone’s spent significant time actually looking…

andy February 27, 2009 at 17:03

The issue with lifeforms on Jupiter-type planets is the severity of turbulence, particularly in the vertical direction. If lifeforms would be rapidly transported between extremes of pressure and temperature, things are rather less promising than if there are more stable regions.

As for science fictional depictions, why hasn’t Wheelers by Ian Stewart and Jack Cohen been mentioned yet?

Adam February 28, 2009 at 4:08

Hi andy

I have Wheelers but I’ve never read it. Something annoyed me about their writing when I started so I never finished. Worth persevering do you think?

andy February 28, 2009 at 12:31

Well Wheelers is pretty much a fictional elaboration of Evolving the Alien, it has interesting ideas but I wouldn’t say it’s great. Same goes for the sequel.

ljk February 28, 2009 at 17:36

Ben Bova’s 2000 SF novel Jupiter deals with huge native life forms
that exist in the layer of water that may girdle the planet. There
were also aerial creatures but he focused on the aquatic ones.

Here is an interview with Bova on the subject:

http://www.astrobio.net/news/article933.html

To quote from the Bova interview:

AM: You say that Jupiter may be the most likely place to find extraterrestrial life, since the planet has organics, water and energy. Yet Jupiter is rarely seen as a likely place for life by most astrobiologists. Do you have any thoughts about what sort of creatures could exist there?

BB: Most scientists ignore Jupiter because of the enormous difficulties of exploring the planet. However, in my novel “Jupiter” I postulated a biosphere that included airborne species below the Jovian cloud deck, and gigantic aquatic species in the planet-wide ocean that girdles Jupiter.

In the 2001 novel series, Clarke briefly discussed the life forms
that dwelled in the atmosphere of Jupiter until the Monolith Aliens
turned Jupiter into a star. The aliens knew the floaters existed,
but decided that the Europan life forms had a better chance of
evolving into an intelligent species so they went ahead and lit
up Jupiter and bye bye floaters.

andy March 1, 2009 at 8:24

I’m not entirely convinced by Bova’s model of the interior structure of Jupiter. Any “ocean” would probably be hydrogen not water… maybe on Neptune it’d be more watery.

ljk March 2, 2009 at 15:58

Carl Sagan had thought about life in a Jovian atmosphere going
back to the 1960s. In the 1966 Time Life Science series book
Planets, which Sagan edited and where you can see his early
influence on the work, there was a two-page spread on such
creatures. Here is that artwork:

http://www.projectrho.com/rocket/zeppelin.jpg

If that page fails to work, go to this page and scroll down
about halfway (lots of interesting aliens on it to boot):

http://www.projectrho.com/rocket/rocket3aa.html

ljk March 16, 2009 at 14:52

http://www.universetoday.com/2009/03/16/indian-balloon-experiment-nets-three-new-bacteria/

March 16, 2009

Indian Balloon Experiment Nets Three New Bacteria

Written by Anne Minard

Indian scientists flying a giant balloon experiment have announced the discovery of three new species of bacteria from the stratosphere.

In all, 12 bacterial and six fungal colonies were detected, nine of which, based on gene sequencing, showed greater than 98 percent similarity with reported known species on earth. Three bacterial colonies, however, represented totally new species. All three boast significantly higher UV resistance compared to their nearest phylogenetic neighbors on Earth.

The experiment was conducted using a balloon that measures 26.7 million cubic feet (756,059 cubic meters) carrying 1,000 pounds (459 kg) of scientific payload soaked in liquid Neon. It was flown from the National Balloon Facility in Hyderabad, operated by the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research (TIFR).

An onboard cryosampler contained sixteen evacuated and sterilized stainless steel probes. Throughout the flight, the probes remained immersed in liquid Neon to create a cryopump effect. The cylinders, after collecting air samples from different heights ranging from 20 km to 41 km (12 to 25 miles) above the Earth’s surface, were parachuted down and retrieved. The samples were analyzed by scientists at the Center for Cellular and Molecular Biology in Hyderabad as well as the National Center for Cell Science in Pune for independent confirmation.

One of the new species has been named as Janibacter hoylei, after the astrophysicist Fred Hoyle, the second as Bacillus isronensis recognizing the contribution of ISRO in the balloon experiments which led to its discovery, and the third as Bacillus aryabhata after India’s celebrated ancient astronomer Aryabhata (also the name of ISRO’s first satellite).

The researchers have pointed out in a press release that precautionary measures and controls operating in the experiment inspire confidence that the new species were picked up in the stratosphere.

“While the present study does not conclusively establish the extra-terrestrial origin of microorganisms, it does provide positive encouragement to continue the work in our quest to explore the origin of life,” they added.

This was the second such experiment conducted by ISRO, with the first one in 2001. Even though the first experiment had yielded positive results, the researchers decided to repeat the experiment while exercising extra care to ensure that it was totally free from any terrestrial contamination.

Source: Indian Space Research Organisation

ljk March 24, 2009 at 13:02

March 16, 2009

Family, friends celebrate astrophysicist Ed Salpeter

By Lauren Gold

Physicist Freeman Dyson remembers friend and colleague Ed Salpeter.

One of his first memories of Ed Salpeter, said physics department chair Saul Teukolsky, stems from one of Teukolsky’s first visits to Cornell in the 1970s.

“It was one of those bright sunny days that you get in Ithaca right this time of year,” he told the many dozens of admirers who gathered in Barnes Hall March 14 to celebrate Salpeter’s life. “Pretty much like today — about 45 degrees, beautiful blue sky … the first hint that maybe the ice age is not going to be permanent.”

Teukolsky, who to that point had lived only in warm climes, was well-bundled against the chill. But “Ed, of course, was in shorts,” he said. “Shorts, a big smile on his face — full of the joys of life.”

Full article here:

http://www.news.cornell.edu/stories/March09/salpeter.memorial.cover.html

No mention of his work with Carl Sagan on the gasbags of Jupiter.

ljk June 10, 2009 at 13:10

The Philosophy of Science Portal on the passing of E. E. Salpeter with
relevant links:

http://philosophyofscienceportal.blogspot.com/2008/11/deceased-edwin-e-salpeter.html

ljk September 15, 2009 at 9:45

Friday, September 11, 2009

Leda Anniversary

35 years ago this week Jupiter’s thirteenth satellite (in order of discovery), Leda, was discovered by Charles T. Kowal.

Full article and discovery image here:

http://palomarskies.blogspot.com/2009/09/leda-anniversary.html

ljk November 2, 2009 at 23:42

November 2, 2009

Jupiter’s Dueling Red Spots

Written by Tammy Plotner

Even though most of us have been suffering from poor seeing conditions due to both hemisphere’s seasonal climate changes, the changes we’re experiencing look like nothing compared to what’s happening on Jupiter. If you think we’ve got turbulent atmosphere and more than our fair share of clouds – then check out what John Chumack’s been watching!

“I captured Jupiter last night (7:45pm EST on 11-01-09) from my backyard in Dayton, but the seeing was rather poor….but I did notice that the Great Red Spot had Company…the Little Red Spot has gotten noticeably redder and is now very close to the GRS.”

Full article here:

http://www.universetoday.com/2009/11/02/jupiters-dueling-red-spots/

ljk September 20, 2010 at 19:26

For those wondering what it might look like if one were floating about the cloudtops of Jupiter, this seems to be a pretty good bet, complete with some Galilean moons and a flock of floaters for good measure – though they look more like hunters in this case:

http://antwrp.gsfc.nasa.gov/apod/ap100915.html

ljk July 8, 2012 at 1:15

Aliens could resemble jellyfish the size of a football field says government advisor

According to a British satellite expert and government adviser the outlandish alien imaginings of Hollywood may not be quite alien enough…

Rob Williams Friday 06 July 2012

From little green men to the crustacean-like ‘prawns’ of ‘District 9′ and H.R.Giger’s nightmarish creation in the ‘Alien’ films – our appetite for imagining how visitors from another planet might look shows no sign of diminishing.

According to a British satellite expert and government adviser, however, the outlandish imaginings of Hollywood may not be quite alien enough.

Dr Maggie Aderin-Pocock – a leading scientist at European space company Astrium – has suggested that, far from being little green men, aliens could actually look like giant jellyfish.

Full article here:

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/aliens-could-resemble-jellyfish-the-size-of-a-football-field-says-government-advisor-7920027.html

ljk May 7, 2013 at 11:33

An artist has imagined a massive creature that might exist floating in the atmosphere of the gas giant world named Polyphemus from the 2009 science fiction film Avatar:

http://natehallinanart.deviantart.com/art/Polyphemus-Gas-Giant-Avatar-158453649

No doubt an inspired relative of the Jovian gasbags Sagan and Salpeter envisioned back in 1976.

The description by artist Nate Hallinan:

“Within the thick clouds of the planet Polyphemus; an elusive colossus exists. It is rare to witness the Polyphemus Gas Giant, but it is a site to behold when one is seen in the open. It emits gases from its porous epidermis as a natural camouflage, a literal smokescreen to blend into its habitat. It is a mystery to how large these graceful creatures are. Eyewitnesses have accounted seeing their tails extending kilometers without being able to see the end. It is still unsure to whether these conjectures are true or not.

“What is known is that the creatures have a natural bioluminescence much like the animals found on Pandora. The Polyfemus Gas Giant uses its bioluminescent tongues to attract swarms of its microbial food. It is speculated that this species may have a distant relation to the animals found on Pandora due to its bioluminescence and its seemingly hexapod like appendages.”

Comments on this entry are closed.

{ 3 trackbacks }