I’m always interesting in discoveries unusually close to the Sun, maybe because I keep hoping that there really is a brown dwarf or rogue planet much closer to our system than Proxima Centauri. In the absence of that discovery, let’s talk about the unusual triple-system that has just turned up thanks to work at the University of Montreal, where the Trottier Institute for Research on Exoplanets (IREx) brings together research from a number of Canadian institutions. Located some 28 light years from Earth, the system has been dubbed Welopōʻai, which is a Hawaiian coinage from the Imiloa Astronomy Center of Hawai’i, an institution whose existence explains some of the Polynesian names that have begun appearing in our astronomical catalogs. In this system, then, we have Welopō‘ai Aa, Welopō‘ai Ab and Welopō‘ai B. I had to resort to AI to retrieve the pronunciation here, and found that it’s weh-loh-POH-eye, which linguistically combines a notion of lineage with the circle depicting an...
The End of Voyager 1’s First Day
One light day. I love the attention being paid to Voyager’s achievement at reaching one light day from Earth. I’m always looking for ways to get across to a public audience the sheer audacity of talking about travel to another star. That means impressing upon them the magnitude of the distances involved. With Voyager 1 now more than 25.9 billion kilometers from Earth (over 16 billion miles), the opportunity presents itself. NASA has responded with its ‘Shine Bright for Voyager’s Light Day’ effort to flash Voyager’s call sign to the heavens. It is a symbolic act reinforcing the dedication it took to get Voyager this far out, and a reminder that both spacecraft are still functioning. The light idea actually takes me back to a James Gunn short story called “The Cave of Night,” which made a splash in Galaxy when it ran in 1955, was soon reprinted and made into a drama on the wonderful X Minus One radio show. Eventually it made a TV appearance I watched in black and white as a kid. In the...
Seeing Planets Awash in Starshine
Finding ways to tweak space missions to rescue data or extend observations is a fascinating process. We’ve seen no shortage of such efforts, from the heroic retrieval of Europa data after the failure of the Galileo mission’s high-grain antenna to the stabilization and ‘rebirth’ of the Kepler space telescope through deft handling of its gyroscopic resources. We can also think about the Voyagers and the continuing measures that keep them working on dwindling power. Now I’m hearing about a new way to handle data gathered by the James Webb Space Telescope. Scientists at Northwestern University have created a technique that relies on slick computation to extract exoplanet images out of the glare of their home star. The data from the mission’s coronagraph are subjected to models superior to existing methods, with the now demonstrated capability of producing new scientific results from the missions’ archives. Glare is everything when it comes to planet imaging. Here’s lead author Rodrigo...
Thinking about Sunshades, Starships and the EarthCup L1 Project
The technologies we will one day use to reach other stars have myriad uses close to home. That’s obvious given the power needed to make an interstellar crossing and the propulsion issues that may be resolved through solar- and lightsail designs and beamed energy solutions. Make an effective solar sail as a driver for interplanetary exploration and you’re already designing with an eye toward scaling up to larger spacecraft and more distant targets. But some of these technologies also have application to our own planet’s habitability. Thus the flurry of activity around adapting solar sails as ‘sunshades,’ designed to intercept solar energy both for easing temperatures on our planet but also for generating power in quantities that could eventually pay for their development. The idea has been kicking around for a while, but I think a good introduction to it is in the essential Paradise Regained: The Regreening of Earth, by Les Johnson, Greg Matloff and C Bangs. The 2010 title should be...
ED138: What a New Dwarf Planet Portends
An intriguing mission to L1 has caught my eye, one with implications for solar sail development as well as climate issues here on Earth. But the research on that story is taking longer than I anticipated, so for today I want to cut to a brief account of the new dwarf planet candidate in the outer Solar System. This is an example of the power of the Vera Rubin Observatory on Cerro Pachón in the Chilean Andes, and a reminder of the numerous discoveries headed our way from its ongoing Legacy Survey of Space and Time, which will produce a high-definition view involving 10 TB of data every night. ED138, which still awaits confirmation, looks to be a fitting companion for Pluto and Ceres in the dwarf planet category, joined by later discoveries Eris, Haumea and Makemake. Each of these last three objects has its own interest as a possible mission destination, with Makemake’s ring system, Haumea’s extreme spin and shape (not to mention its ice moons Hi’iaka and Namaka), and unusually...
Microbes on Enceladus?
Until we get more assets in orbit around Saturn, we're left to studying Cassini data on the fascinating moon Enceladus, findings that have already revealed much about geyser activity at the moon's south polar region and its implications. New lab work is now procovative, as Alex Tolley reports in this morning's essay. While we cannot claim a detection of life, it increasingly appears that the same kind of hot vents that allow life to flourish on the ocean floors of Earth produce nurturing conditions on Enceladus as well. Could an Earth organism survive in the rugged little moon's ocean? As Alex explains, the recent experiments are more than a little encouraging. If a future mission finds evidence of microbes in the Enceladan ocean, we will have not only proven that life exists on another world, but that conditions common on icy moons may support living systems throughout the outer system. by Alex Tolley Introduction Last year, 3i/Atlas, the interstellar comet, eclipsed the important...
Thoughts on Brown Dwarfs, Science Fiction and New Telescopes
Here’s an interesting notion, courtesy of science fiction writer Jack McDevitt. Jack’s story “Lighthouse” (available in Cryptic: The Best Short Fiction of Jack McDevitt (Subterranean Press, 2009) posits an apparently normal brown dwarf that, upon closer study, turns out to be deeply anomalous, in ways that seem designed to call attention to it. There appears to be no intent to establish contact but rather to warn anyone traveling near the object that there is a solitary black hole, all but undetectable, in its immediate vicinity. And there is not just one brown dwarf, but several thousand that display similar anomalies in their spectra, as determined by a survey of these stars throughout the galaxy. Could these markers be a warning system for interstellar travelers? Written with Michael Shara, the story is a nice, compact bit of hard science fiction, working with realistic spectroscopic analysis and ingenious speculation. It’s also realistic about the kind of non-scientific pressures...
Musings on White Dwarfs and Planetary Survival
A research team at the University of Warwick (UK) has turned up what may be a planet orbiting a white dwarf. That’s an interesting find given the lifetime of white dwarfs after the parent star has lost its outer envelope. Any life on such a world would have several billion years to work with (see White Dwarfs and Habitable Planets for more), although this planet is far too young for that. But this find has other implications. If confirmed, it would be the first planet thought to have formed through accretion of materials left over from the death of the red giant. It would be evidence of a second generation, a planet-hosting period that begins after the red giant phase is over. The star is HS 0209+0832, a young and hot white dwarf maybe five million years beyond the red giant phase. The original discovery came in 1999 by way of the Hubble Space Telescope, although the data had remained little studied in the archives since then. It took examination by doctoral candidate Jamie Williams...
Photosynthesis: A New Angle into Fermi’s Paradox?
One of the things that gives the Fermi paradox its punch is the age of the galaxy. Back in 1950 when Fermi uttered his famous ‘Where is everybody?’ question, ideas about how old the Milky Way was were all over the map. Working with Hubble’s constant as understood at the time, the entire universe looked to be no more than 2 billion years old, a problem given what we were learning about the age of the Earth itself based on radioactive dating. So workarounds were needed, and they included the then widely supported steady-state theory, which saw a universe without beginning or end. Then too, the problem of the age of the galaxy could not be satisfactorily worked out because we had no good methods to gauge the age of individual stars. A book could be written about the evolution of our thinking on both age problems, but for now, let’s say that Fermi asked his question about extraterrestrials at a time when values for the age of the galaxy were generally set at between 3 and 5 billion...
Sakurai’s Object: A Stellar Rebirth
Given how long stars live in comparison to human lifetimes, I always do a double-take at science fiction tales of starships dropping in to study a nova just as it’s about to go off. I suppose we have to assume the starship civilization has found a way to time such matters. There’s a Star Trek: The Next Generation episode that involves rescuing a planetary population from a star that’s about to explode (“A Fury Scorned”), but of all the nova arrivals, I like Samuel Delany’s 1968 novel Nova the best. Here, in order to harvest a rare element dubbed ‘Illyrion,’ the exact moment of the explosion has to be known and exploited through a mind-bending run through the debris. Today’s paper doesn’t involve a nova, but it does involve a star that is doing things on a very short timeframe indeed. The star is known as Sakurai’s Object (V4334 Sagittarii). Japanese amateur Yukio Sakurai observed the object in 1996, noting how it appeared to be brightening. A 1976 detection of the progenitor star had...
Disrupted Systems: Implications for Life
Anthropocentric thinking is a persistent problem when we’re talking about extraterrestrial civilizations. Some of our most cherished notions can be invoked so effortlessly as to defy the imagination. The Copernican idea that life must exist elsewhere because elsewhere is bound to be more or less like here has had a long lifetime in SETI studies. It seems like the most basic common sense. And yet, as we’ll see once again today, scientific results continue to make it apparent that the fact that we are here does not mean that they are there. Finding stellar systems more or less like our own continues to be difficult. I’m not going full ‘rare Earth’ here but acknowledging that our circumstances may be unusual enough to tamp down estimates of the number of life-supporting planets. For that matter, our lack of knowledge about abiogenesis itself makes the case that we cannot necessarily expect it around other suns. On this matter, at least, we should be able to gather data soon, perhaps...
Pandora: Tuning Up our Data on Exoplanet Atmospheres
Launching a flagship-class mission like the Roman Space Telescope is always exciting, but with Roman in space, let’s also keep an eye on Pandora, a smaller though fascinating NASA mission (through its Astrophysics Pioneers program) that is now beginning its own work in exoplanet science. 20 exoplanets are targeted here, the idea being to work with data from transits to characterize their atmospheres via transmission spectroscopy, but with an additional twist. Elisa Quintana,(NASA GSFC) is principal investigator: "Pandora’s data will help close a major gap in our knowledge about planets and their host stars because, right now, we can’t be entirely sure how the star’s light affects measurements of what makes up exoplanet atmospheres. We designed the Pandora spacecraft and its in-depth observing program to better understand this vexing issue.” Launched January 11 of this year, Pandora is now beginning observations of its target stars. It’s in that category of smallsats that fascinate me...
Fermi Explorer: Building the First Mission to Another Star?
The question of when to launch an interstellar mission has occupied us many times in the past. Specifically, how long do we wait so that travel times are reduced to something like the lifetime of a researcher working on the project? But there is another approach to all this. Someone is going to launch an interstellar mission that will be the first human effort to send a payload to another star. It’s all about intentionality and the choice of targets. A symbolic act? Sure, but don’t write the idea off. We can learn a lot from symbolic acts, and if we only have, at our current level of technology, the ability to reach Voyager-like speeds, we can still work on issues like equipment lifetimes, self-healing technologies, navigational issues and more. We can also work to refine existing AI tools to achieve the most efficient design. If we give ourselves 80,000 years to reach Alpha Centauri, we have to contend with the fact that the system is constantly moving. On this timeframe, by the...
Roman Space Telescope Launches Tomorrow
We’ll have a lot to talk about when observations from the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope start coming in. But first we’ve got to get it out to its halo orbit around the L2 Sun-Earth Lagrange point. With the Sun, Earth and Moon permanently blocked out, the seeing should be good from this vantage some 1.5 million kilometers out. Just now I’ve had a note from Jim Benford reminding me that launch is currently scheduled for tomorrow, August 30, at 0726 ET (1126 UTC). The additional good news is that Jim’s son Dominic will be one of two hosts of the live coverage from NASA. I remember meeting Dominic some years back at Goddard Space Flight Center, where I had the chance to see the JWST telescope being prepared to go through its vibration testing. Dominic has spent more than a decade working on the Roman telescope, so the honor of working the NASA live coverage is well deserved. The photo below shows him during preparations for the Sunday coverage, which starts at 0620 ET (1020 UTC). You...
A ‘Time Variable’ Feature on Pluto?
With New Horizons now 63 AU out, it’s time to ponder that record hibernation period that the spacecraft just went through. Over 10 months long, this one had the same goal as previous such periods, to hold down operating costs but also give a break to onboard instrumentation in hopes of augmenting mission lifetime. As a kid, I often thought how cool it would be to be involved with a distant spacecraft. For some reason I always visualized this as being here on Earth while working with a craft beyond the Solar System. So maybe I was dreaming more of being a flight controller than an astronaut. I hadn’t realized until reading Alan Stern’s recent update that while hibernation means there are no commands and responses going back and forth, the craft does continue active data gathering from its Solar Wind at Pluto (SWAP) plasma detector and the Pluto Energetic Particle Spectrometer Science Investigation (PEPSSI) instrument. The Student Dust Counter is also in operation. Since awaking early...
The Limits of Understanding Between Species, and the Issue for Interstellar Communication
We've yet to find any evidence of intelligent life beyond Earth, a puzzling failure given the widespread belief that where habitable planets exist, life will somehow emerge. If we do receive a signal, though, would we be able to understand it? We've made some progress in piecing together animal communications here on Earth, but figuring out what the whistles and clicks of sea creatures mean remains a work in progress. In today's essay, associate editor Alex Tolley goes to work on key questions: Is mathematics truly a universal language? Does language change how we experience the world, and if so, what aspects of an alien culture will we actually be able to understand? The questions are daunting and now coming into public discourse in the realm of AI. Alex's thoughts on that phenomenon and how we might interact with a machine civilization are only part of the interest here. by Alex Tolley Introduction Discussions about alien communication usually focus on the technology of message...
The Ones Who Look Outward
Thinking about a great filter through which a civilization must pass before its survival is assured usually leads to catastrophic scenarios, such as planetary suicide by nuclear war, or climate holocaust (assuming the filter lies ahead of us and not behind). But filters may be more subtle and tied in with epistemology. How does intelligence view its place in the universe and thereby engage with other beings? In today’s essay, Ian Brownlie looks at the matter from the standpoint of how knowledge is acquired and transmitted. Based in New Zealand (near Hawke’s Bay on the North Island), Ian is an Electrical Engineer who works with commissioning high voltage complex power systems. The survival and evolution of technology may be a harder step than we think. by Ian Brownlie, BE(E&E) Intelligence has appeared on Earth in many forms. Science-like inquiry has appeared more than once. But sustained, cumulative science appears to be different. It survives across generations, sharpens its own...
Detection of a Habitable Zone Planet with an Atmosphere
If we couldn’t figure out what to call CD-35 2722B b, which I assume is the correct way to refer to the planet-sized object in this red dwarf / brown dwarf/ gas giant system, another planet has a bit of a definitional problem as well. LHS 1140 b is an interesting super-Earth orbiting a red dwarf in Cetus in its habitable zone. Some 49 light years out, this planet is almost 6 times Earth’s mass and boasts a radius 1.7 times larger. Receiving 42 percent of the stellar radiation that Earth does, its surface temperatures allow the presence of liquid water. But exactly what kind of planet is this? Is it an airless, rocky world, an ocean planet, or even a mini-Neptune? We can probably rule out the latter because its mass would be low for that category, and we can also, contrary to some press reports, not consider it in any way, shape or form ‘Earth-like.’ But thanks to new work out of Harvard and the Carnegie Institution for Science, we can now declare that it does have an atmosphere. This...
Moon or Planet? The Awkward Case of CD-35 2722B
Problems of definition will long be with us as we take ever closer looks at exoplanets. But they’re suddenly on everyone’s mind because of the detection of what some are calling an ‘exomoon’ in the system CD-35 2722, found in the constellation Columba. The primary in this system is an M-dwarf thought to be 50–200 million years old. I imagine there is no shortage of flare activity on this star, although the paper doesn’t get into that. The interesting finding in this work just published in Nature is expressed in its title: “Planetary-Mass Exosatellite Detected Around a Star’s Substellar Companion.” Image: This illustration shows the system around the star CD-35 2722, with the newly found moon-like object at the centre. The star –– the point source to the left –– has about half the mass of our Sun, and it is orbited by a brown dwarf, the reddish-brown object seen here in the foreground (right). The brown dwarf has about 37 times the mass of Jupiter: too massive to be a planet, but not...
New Propulsion Systems for Deep Space Smallsats
Building the infrastructure we will need for interstellar exploration requires an imaginative look at today’s technologies as applied to distant targets. Indeed, we can leverage the scientific interest in, say, an orbit around each of the ice giants to explore launch capabilities through beamed energy, but we will also need to consider how we can use economical smallsats to provide stationkeeping nodes in such studies. Advances in miniaturization and the growing sophistication of CubeSats all point in the same direction. We can exploit our early flybys by fleshing out an observational smallsat matrix around targets at system’s edge to form a robust data and communications network. The thing that is going to vitalize the development of small satellite packages is a new kind of propulsion system of the sort recently developed at MIT. The problem is easily stated: A small spacecraft – think suitcase size or less – has to maximize payload while ensuring flexibility in adjusting...

