Images of distant exoplanets, once only a wish for future space missions, have begun to turn up with a certain regularity. The three planets around HR8799 and the single gas giant around Fomalhaut were announced on the same day, while a week later we once again have Beta Pictoris in focus, a young star so well studied that images of its dust disk go back to the mid-1980s. A new analysis of 2003 data from the Very Large Telescope now brings a team of French astronomers to offer a probable -- but not certain -- image of what may turn out to be Beta Pictoris b. The observations seem to show a gas giant some eight times more massive than Jupiter, orbiting at roughly 8 AU, not far inside Saturn's orbit in our own Solar System. But astronomer Gael Chauvin (Laboratoire d’Astrophysique de l’Observatoire de Grenoble) is quick to qualify the finding: "We cannot yet rule out definitively, however, that the candidate companion could be a foreground or background object. To eliminate this very...
An Internet for Deep Space
Networking deep space should be a priority for future missions. If we can set up robust networking between spacecraft, we relieve the Deep Space Network of a huge burden, that of having to communicate directly with each spacecraft for tasks that are essentially routine. No more maneuvering huge dishes to catch one fleeting signal, at least not for missions to come. Instead, we could rely on spacecraft to create their own file transfers, move their own traffic to astronauts (remember the video mail in 2001: A Space Odyssey?), and manage local operations. Why not use the Internet we've already got? Unfortunately, the TCP/IP (Transmission Control Protocol/Internet Protocol) tools we use today are 'chatty,' a term that means the computers that run them exchange data over and over again through the course of a transaction. Suppose you want to send a file through FTP (File Transfer Protocol). Doing so takes eight round trips of data between the computers involved before the file can be...
High-Energy Electrons: Evidence for Dark Matter?
What is the unusual source of high-energy cosmic rays that has been discovered within 3000 light years of the Sun? Everyone loves a mystery, and this one has all the earmarks of a classic. The source was found by the Advanced Thin Ionization Calorimeter (ATIC) experiment, which was lofted to high altitude above Antarctica via helium-filled balloon. Behind the experiment was the goal of studying cosmic rays that are otherwise shielded from the surface by the Earth's atmosphere, but among the results was an unexpected finding. Cosmic ray electrons at 300 to 800 billion electron volts are simply too powerful to be regarded as standard fare, for these particles lose energy as they move through the galaxy. That means that a study like this should see fewer electrons at higher energies. Nearby sources, on the other hand, stand out, making it clear there is what principal investigator John Wefel (Louisiana State) calls "...a very interesting object near our solar system waiting to be...
Searching for Dyson Spheres
A Dyson Sphere makes an extraordinary setting for science fiction. In fact, my first knowledge of the concept came from reading Larry Niven's 1970 novel Ringworld, a book that left such an impression that I still recall reading half of it at a sitting in the drafty little parlor of a house I was renting in Grinnell, Iowa. Ringworld had just come out as a Ballantine paperback with the lovely cover you see below. I was hooked after about three pages and read deep into a night filled with wind and snow. It could be argued, of course, that a ring made out of planetary material, a habitat so vast that it completely encircles its star, is actually one of the smaller Dyson concepts. It was in 1960 that Freeman Dyson suggested how a civilization advanced to the point of such astro-engineering might use everything it found in its solar system to create a cloud of objects, a swarm that would make the most efficient use of its primary's light. And as you keep adding objects, you point to the...
Billions of Positrons Created in Laboratory
Irradiate a millimeter-thick gold target with the right kind of laser and you might get a surprise in the form of 100 billion positrons, the antimatter equivalent of electrons. Researchers had been studying the process at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, where they used thin targets that produced far fewer positrons. The new laser method came about through simulations that showed a thicker target was more effective. And suddenly lasers and antimatter are again making news. Hui Chen is the Livermore scientist behind this work: "We've detected far more anti-matter than anyone else has ever measured in a laser experiment. We've demonstrated the creation of a significant number of positrons using a short-pulse laser." Image: Physicist Hui Chen sets up targets for the antimatter experiment at the Jupiter laser facility. Credit: Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory. What's happening here is that ionized electrons are interacting with gold nuclei, giving off energy that decays into...
Reflections on Visible Exoplanets
The images of planets around Fomalhaut and HR8799 carried more clout than I expected, with traffic to the site quadrupling when the story ran, and substantial coverage from major media outlets as well. I ran the exciting images of both stars and their companions, but because I enjoy astronomical artwork, I now want to include the visualization below, showing Fomalhaut b surrounded by a large ring of autumnal russet and gold. Note, too, the extensive debris disk surrounding the distant star. Orbiting every 872 years, Fomalhaut b lies some 2.9 billion kilometers inside that disk's inner edge. Credit: ESA, NASA, and L. Calcada (ESO for STScI). Greg Laughlin (University of California, Santa Cruz) was surprised at the even-handed media treatment of HR8799, considering the brightness of Fomalhaut ('A star with a name like a rocket'), not to mention the acknowledged skills of the Hubble Space Telescope's media office. But while HR8799 isn't exactly a household word, the faint object trumps...
Science Fiction: Future Past
Be sure to have a look at New Scientist's special coverage of science fiction, from which this (in an article by Marcus Chown): "As well as a mere storytelling device, science fiction often articulates our present-day concerns and anxieties - paradoxically, it is often about the here and now rather than the future. As Stephen Baxter points out..., H. G. Wells's ground-breaking 1895 novella The Time Machine - famous for popularising the idea of time travel - was more concerned with where Darwinian natural selection was taking the human race than with the actual nuts and bolts of time travel. In the 1968 novel Stand on Zanzibar, John Brunner imagined the dire consequences of overpopulation. Arthur C. Clarke's The Lion of Comarre explored the terrible allure of computer-generated artificial realities, which - god forbid - people might actually choose over the far-from-seductive messiness of the real world. All of these books are about imagining where present-day, often worrying,...
Life’s Traces in Mineral Evolution
Now here's a comprehensive task for you. Take about a dozen primordial minerals found in interstellar dust grains and figure out what processes -- physical, chemical, biological -- led to the appearance of the thousands of minerals we find on our planet today. The job was undertaken by Robert Hazen and Dominic Papineau (Carnegie Institution Geophysical Laboratory) and colleagues, and it produced startling results: Of the roughly 4300 known types of minerals on Earth (fifty new types identified each year), up to two-thirds can be linked to biological activity. Mineral evolution? In a sense, although Hazen is quick to qualify the statement: "It's a different way of looking at minerals from more traditional approaches. Mineral evolution is obviously different from Darwinian evolution — minerals don't mutate, reproduce or compete like living organisms. But we found both the variety and relative abundances of minerals have changed dramatically over more than 4.5 billion years of...
Exoplanet Images: Two Observational Coups
Are we really moving beyond indirect detection methods to being able to produce actual images of extrasolar planets? Apparently so, as witness the first direct images of multiple planets around a normal main sequence star. And on the same day, we have the announcement of a visible light image of a Jupiter-class planet orbiting the star Fomalhaut, one suspected for several years because of the sharply defined inner edge of the dust belt around the star. A planet in an elliptical orbit affecting the debris disk had been thought to be offsetting the inner edge of the belt. Let's go to the planets found around the dusty young star HR8799 first. They range from seven to ten times the mass of Jupiter. Bruce Macintosh (Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory), one of the authors of a new paper on the achievement in Science Express, explains its significance: "Every extrasolar planet detected so far has been a wobble on a graph. These are the first pictures of an entire system. We've been...
An Inflatable Sail to the Oort Cloud
Want to get to the outer Solar System quickly? Try this on for size: Two and a half years to reach the heliopause, six and a half years to get to the Sun's inner gravitational focus (550 AU), with arrival at the inner Oort Cloud in no more than thirty years. A spacecraft meeting those targets is moving at 403 kilometers per second, roughly twenty times as fast as anything we've put into space before. Such a mission could perform useful astrophysical observations enroute, explore gravitational focusing techniques, and image Oort Cloud objects while exploring particles and fields in that region that are of galactic rather than solar origin. The combined Oort Cloud explorer/gravity focus probe grows out of work by Gregory Matloff and Roman Kezerashvili (CUNY), Italian physicist Claudio Maccone and Les Johnson (NASA MSFC). Matloff, of course, has been studying solar sail technologies for decades, looking at missions that could reach velocities in the range of 0.003c-0.004c, with metallic...
A SETI-based Look at New Horizons
Using eleven of the Allen Telescope Array's 6.1-meter dishes, the SETI Institute and the Radio Astronomy Laboratory at the University of California (Berkeley) have detected the New Horizons spacecraft on its way to Pluto/Charon. New Horizons transmits an 8.4 GHz carrier signal that showed up readily on the SETI Prelude detection system. What I hadn't realized was that snagging distant spacecraft transmitters is a standard part of SETI operations, as Jill Tarter notes in this brief article on the event posted at the New Horizons site: "We look forward to checking in with New Horizons as a routine, end-to-end test of our system health. As this spacecraft travels farther, and its signals grow weaker, we will be building out the Allen Telescope Array from 42 to 350 antennas, and thus can look forward to a long-term relationship." Image: New Horizons as tracked by the Allen Telescope Array. This plot shows 678 hertz (Hz) of spectrum collected over 98 seconds. The New Horizons signal can...
Notes & Queries 11/10/08
Larry Klaes sends along links to four of Fred Hoyle and Chandra Wickramasinghe's books on panspermia, now available online. I first encountered the duo's Evolution from Space shortly after its publication in 1981, found it curious and unlikely, and went on to other things. But the idea that a microbe might make its way between planets is under greater scrutiny than ever, even if the concept of interstellar panspermia remains contentious. And I think Larry sums the matter up nicely: "Certain ideas in these works have become a bit more accepted, or at least less further from the mainstream than when they first came out. They do make for very interesting reading whether you agree with their ideas or not." The Cosmic Ancestry site offers resources on the topic here, including PDF's of Hoyle and Wickramasinghe's Space Travelers: The Bringers of Life, Viruses from Space, Living Comets and Proofs That Life Is Cosmic. ------- I'm looking at a stunning image of Saturn's rings, with a huge,...
A Balloon in Titan’s Skies
The pace of change being what it is, adjusting our time frames can be a difficult task. That's particularly true in the planning of space missions, where the gap between what we seem able to do and the actual window for doing it can become as large as it is frustrating. NASA and the European Space Agency, for example, will make a choice in 2009 between a Jupiter/Europa mission and a project called the Titan and Saturn System Mission (TSSM). Whichever is chosen, the projected launch date is at least twelve years away, with arrival expected no earlier than 2030. The lengthy interval is the inevitable result of the complexity of mission planning and the realities of orbital mechanics. We're always in a hurry about space missions because we're so anxious for new information, but absent propulsion breakthroughs, we're still tied to multi-decade planning cycles. Even so, as we investigate ways to fly missions faster, the prospect of what we might do with the Titan and Saturn mission looms...
New Study: Centauri B Planets Unlikely
Roughly twenty percent of all detected exoplanets are in binary systems, intensifying our interest in Alpha Centauri. Recent work, however, has been less than encouraging to those hoping to find one or more terrestrial worlds around these stars. Indeed, Philippen Thébault (Stockholm Observatory), Francesco Marzari (University of Padova) and Hans Scholl (Observatoire de la Côte d’Azur) have shown that in the case of Centauri A, the zone beyond 0.5 AU is hostile to the accretion processes that allow planets to form. Any terrestrial-class world that close to Centauri A would be excluded from the habitable zone, a region thought to extend from 1.0 to 1.3 AU around the star. The same team now goes to work on Centauri B, having pointed out in the earlier paper that the mathematical modeling it used there was unique to Centauri A and could not be applied indiscriminately to other systems, not even to the second star of the Centauri binary. The authors are targeting the phase of planetary...
A Lunar Refuge for Early Microbes
The Moon is, for obvious reasons, rarely considered an interesting venue for astrobiology. But I've been looking through Joop Houtkooper's presentation at the European Planetary Science Congress, noting his contention that some lunar craters might hold samples of life from the early Earth, and perhaps even from Mars. If the name Houtkooper rings a bell, it may stem from the splash he made last year by suggesting that the Viking probes to Mars may have discovered Martian microbes consisting of fifty percent water and fifty percent hydrogen peroxide. Although some extremophiles here on Earth put hydrogen peroxide to use, the theory is quite a long shot. But then, Houtkooper (University of Giessen, Germany) seems to thrive on remote possibilities. His lunar theory works like this: Certain craters on the Moon are effectively shielded from sunlight, at least deep within their recesses. Shackleton crater at the south pole is a case in point, a place that may contain sub-craters free of...
A Surprising Find from the Early Solar System
As if we didn't have enough trouble piecing together how planets form, we're now learning that objects much smaller than planets -- the planetesimals that collide and agglomerate to form planet-sized objects -- can be the subject of melting. The work, led by Benjamin Weiss at MIT, suggests that objects on the scale of 160 kilometers across were large enough to melt almost completely, a counter-intuitive notion that would explain the magnetism found in certain meteorites, which until now has remained a mystery. Weiss' team studied the record of this magnetic field as preserved in three angrite meteorites from the early Solar System. Such study is known as paleomagnetism, examining the record of magnetic fields as preserved in various magnetic minerals, and the angrites involved are thought to record the earliest stages of planet formation. The record of their magnetism extends beyond the lifetime of the early circumstellar disk, leading Weiss to conclude that the fields were produced...
The Hunt for Ancient Antimatter
Antimatter's great attraction from a propulsion standpoint is the ability to convert 100 percent of its mass into energy, a reaction impossible with fission or fusion methods. The trick, of course, is to find enough antimatter to use. We can produce it in particle accelerators but only in amounts that are vanishingly small. There is evidence that it is produced naturally, at least in trace amounts, in the relativistic jets produced by black holes and pulsars. Indeed, a cloud of antimatter 10,000 light years across has been described around our own galaxy's center. And at least one scientist, James Bickford (Draper Laboratory), has worked out ways to extract antimatter produced here in the Solar System, a method that he believes would be five orders of magnitude more cost effective than creating the stuff on Earth. But what about early antimatter, particles left over from the earliest days of the universe? According to prevalent theory, the universe may have been awash with the stuff...
A Beacon-Oriented Strategy for SETI
I've spent so much recent time on two SETI/METI papers by James, Gregory and Dominic Benford because they contain powerful arguments for re-thinking our current SETI strategy. By analyzing how we might construct cost-optimized interstellar beacons, the authors ask what those beacons might look like if other civilizations were turning them toward us. The results are striking: A distant beacon operating for maximum effect consistent with rational expense would offer up a pulsed signal that will be short and intermittent, recurring over periods of a month or year. It will, in other words, be unlike the kind of persistent signal that conventional SETI is optimized to search for. Searches designed to sweep past stars quickly, hoping to find long-lasting beacons whose signature would be apparent, would rarely notice oddball signals that seem to come out of nowhere and then vanish. Tracking such signals, looking for signs of regularity and repetition, calls for a different strategy. Image:...
METI: Learning from Efficient Beacons
If we want to consider how to pick up transmissions from a distant civilization, it pays to consider the most effective strategies for building interstellar beacons here on Earth. This is the method James, Gregory and Dominic Benford have used in twin papers on SETI/METI issues, papers that should be read in conjunction since the METI questions play directly into our SETI reception strategies. It pays to have a microwave specialist like James Benford on the case. Our METI transmissions to date have used radio telescopes and microwaves to send messages to nearby stars. Longer distances will cost more and take much more power. How much would a true interstellar beacon cost, one not limited to the relatively short ranges of recent METI transmissions? Count on something on the order of $10 billion. As to power, Jim is able to quantify the amount. To reach beyond roughly a thousand light years with a microwave beacon, an Effective Isotropic Radiated Power (EIRP) greater than 1017 W must...
SETI: Figuring Out the Beacon Builders
Several interesting papers on SETI have appeared in recent days, among them Gregory, James and Dominic Benford's attempt to place SETI in the context of economics. Equally useful is Duncan Forgan's new look at the Drake Equation, presenting a way to estimate the distribution of the crucial parameters. I'll bypass the Forgan paper temporarily because I've asked Marc Millis to tackle it as soon as he gets back from the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, where he's gone to attend a workshop. Forgan's study has direct bearing on a Tau Zero initiative we hope to have in place by the end of the year and thus is a natural for Marc to write up. But back to the Benfords, who have offered up twin papers (as seems reasonable for the brothers), one on SETI (with Gregory as principal author) and the other on its METI offshoot (transmitting messages rather than listening for them). James Benford is lead author on the latter. This work is so rich that I won't try to encapsulate it in a single post, but...